Back to the Hutch, and it is nearly two weeks since doing so. It has taken a while to 'land'. Am struggling to get very much done at the physical level. A lot of thinking done, of course. That's the YAMster's pattern. Work it all out... then BAM! Suddenly there is movement at the station, and it kinda all happens at once. But not yet.
I have managed to get all the posts up to date here and one more video out - there's another in process. I have caught up on some reading and viewing, and listening. I have caught up on some crochet (a leftover patchwork squares thing, making it up as I go along). Caught up on laundry and a tidy-up. All of this is to work up to starting the big declutter of the Hutch. I just have to get myself going.
Today, though, I will review the technicalities of running The Grey around 1470 miles of these isles. Yes, all but 1500 flat.
As pointed out in several other posts, The Grey is big. He's got quite the backside. The first and ongoing issue I faced when it came to parking - mainly regarding charging the vehicle, as the overnights were generally in places unfettered with other units - was that we just needed to fit into the dinky car spaces provided. The majority of the charge points accessed were within established car parking facilities.
Which presented other issues, too. First, the spacing. The length and width of the bays in many car parks are skimmed down to the absolute minimum. Which is not horrendous if the park is not busy. If the bays are packed, turning into some of them would take a bit of to and fro. Then the back end would be sticking into the flow of others needing to leave. It did come to a point that if I saw such conditions, I just drove by and looked for another charger.
Then there were the many and varied parking conditions within those facilities. For the most part, the council-run parks in England are using private collection companies for payment... and virtually all the car parking facilities I came across south of the Border were pay-for-stay. I didn't mind that in those where I was choosing to park up for the night and spend time. But when one is charging one's vehicle, it seems like a case of double-dipping. I came across only one place where it was made clear that charging meant no parking fees...
Well done to the Howden council for that one. Some of you may recall that in another place outside Manchester, another driver was under the impression she never had to pay parking fees... but I fear she must just have gotten by on sheer luck. All the parks with chargers I used in England had boards stating all the fees - and all the penalties that would be enforced if the list of conditions was not met. Frankly, the language in the small print could be classed as bullying or even threatening. Here's the thing - drivers are expected to stop and read all that stuff before buying their ticket. Here's an example - and this one is quite simple compared to some I met.
image from Signway |
The devil is in the details, like the place where, in one of the last sentences in the bottom right small print part, it indicated that there was a height and weight restriction on the vehicles entering those premises... which meant that The Grey was illegal and up for potential £70 fine. It was late on a Saturday arvo, so I didn't panic. Then there was the one where that lady was saying it didn't matter, but I couldn't see any let out on the board... but then discovered that parking meter only operated with hard coin. Then the warden came along and had a good look around. I seemed to have been okay in the end, but there was some concern. It doesn't make sense that vehicle charge points should be penalised for access like that.
The next issue with access is that the apps often indicated chargers available - but failed to alert one that it was behind barriers due to the car park belonging to a commercial business and was for patrons only. I am fairly sure that the charger owners themselves would want their units to be publically accessible - if they are only for businesses on whose land they sit, they ought not to appear on the apps.
As I have also mentioned, another aspect is that there are many different charging facilities. The Blue Oval RFID fob I have covers me for some MER, some Gridserve, all BPPulse, all ChargePlace and Osprey points, Ionity and ShellRecharge, and maybe some others... but there is no actual listing to alert me, and the app for that combined payment service isn't the most functional. I am also signed up to ChargePlace Scotland - which, it turned out, also covered a few chargers in and around the Midlands - yet not in the two obvious counties of Cumbria and Northumbria. I did sign up with PodPoint in the end to have at least one more option open to me, but that particular matter was starting to do my head in. This is one reason I didn't hang around there, particularly in Cumbria. Currently, on ZapMap, there are 53 different suppliers listed. How would petrol/diesel drivers feel if there were 53 different fuel suppliers, each with different machines to negotiate and different cards or apps to pay with? I have been reading and viewing various articles/programs on this issue and the need for significant regulation to standardise EV charging supply.
Similarly, some better checks concerning costs - and maintenance, and quantity. Certainly, the number of charge points is increasing, but it really needs to speed up. Maintenance... I didn't have much trouble with this until after leaving Nottingham and into the northwest. Around the Manchester area, there were enough for it not to be a huge issue. Once I got into the Yorkshire Dales, some cracks started to appear. Not only were the facilities more restricted (by my choosing to stick to specific networks), but every second point seemed to need to be fixed. Is it overuse? Is it that drivers in those areas are just very kak-handed? Are there saboteurs? Oh, I could write screeds... As to costs, these varied quite widely, but on the whole, south of the Border, the charges are significantly more than in Scotland.
One of the frustrations was that, where there were options of fast DC charging or the slower AC charging, there was no differentiation, and the higher cost seemed always to be extracted. The costs were also much higher anywhere that was remotely busy or touristy. The northwest route also had me having to use motorway service chargers, and those (like fuel) come at premium pricing. By that, I mean around 90p per kWh. A quick glance back over ZapMap shows me that the average cost per kWh at most chargers I used was 59p. When I got north of the Border again, the costs became less. Now, I will be doing more driving in the Bonny Land to test out the standard and overall costs here, but as things stand, I would place the average here to be closer to 30p - which is less per kW than I am paying for the power in The Hutch. One thing that has been happening is the limiting of time and the cost of overstaying at a charger. This is to encourage a level of etiquette; not to have drivers just leave their cars for hours on end and block the space even if their battery is full. This is fine if you have the 43kWh charger - if you're on the 11kWh, that's not much charge in 70 mins (or 90 or whatever is allotted). Still, little and often remember!
What about The Grey itself? How did we go along? After the initial trepidatious hook-ups in which it all felt a tad clumsy, by the time I had reached Lincolnshire on the southbound journey, I was starting to feel like I knew what I was doing. By the time I reached Havant, I knew that overconfidence could be an issue too! Mostly, though, we managed well. The mindset for EV driving is necessarily different from ICE driving. In the latter, we tend to drive until the needle is down below the quarter tank (or even lower), then seek a station and fill the tank to full again. There is no need to think about fuel until that needle peskily gets near the E marker again. It makes no difference to the engine how much fuel is there or how much goes in - just so long as it is not empty and sucking air.
With an EV, one must think more in terms of little and often charging. Lithium batteries are better for not being totally drained (too often) or for being fully charged too quickly, too often. Thus, the guidance is to charge when dropping below 40% and mostly to 80 or 85%. Also, use ultra-fast charging sparingly. With its power-on-board capabilities in the E-Transit, this works well because 40% works out at about 70-75 miles range. Charging up the Bluetti uses about five miles of range. While I could set the battery to permit dropping below sixty miles in range to make that charge, I only did that if I was sure there was a working charge point within cooee. I was amazed to discover that we averaged three miles per kWh used. It has to be accepted that The Grey was travelling light - not yet fully furnished - but even with another 350-400 kgs on board, I think I might expect over the two miles per unit of power, which is at the top end of the suggested likely given by Ford themselves. This means a better range. The average suggested for this vehicle is about 120 miles per full charge. The highest charge I gave Grey on the trip was 93%, and the projected mileage was 183 miles... so 100% might be closer to 200. This is well above expectation, and while I am prepared for that dropping as the weight goes on and the winter approaches, I am well-pleased with my Big Grey Steed! Obviously, more power is required to go up in the hillier areas, but using the super eco function on Grey, there was a decent amount of regain on the downward, too - enough to balance things out as if on the flat. The miles per power unit were also less in places where I had to use the brakes more - that is to say, when driving in towns and cities. In theory, this ought to be the opposite, but the traffic flow means that one cannot avoid the use of brakes and cannot rely purely on the one-pedal deceleration/regain. We did best on the open road where we could pootle along at 40/45 mph.
Tying all that together, how did I fare on my six-week holiday? Well, in charging terms, I added the parking fees as part of the costs, as I couldn't charge unless I paid them (at least not without the risk of even higher costs!) It came out at 19.93p per mile... which is definitely on the high side if you compare it with ICE vehicles. There is no doubt that in going on another similar trip south, I have learned heaps about locating and using chargers, as well as becoming more secure in what The Grey needs versus what my mind needs, so I am fairly sure I could cut that cost down some. Though, as you have seen, there are many factors involved and to some degree, EV drivers are being held to ransom at the moment!
However, I chose to look at my total costs as well. Not counting the very personal things such as clothes and RRD (rollator), but thinking in terms of groceries, eating out, fees/donations for other things, and adding that to the energy costs, I spent just shy of, so let's round it up to, £400. For 42 days, that works out at £9.52 per day.
When did you last have a vacation with comfy accommodations, transport, food and lots of fantastic scenery and places to visit for under ten quid a day? (Twenty Aussie bucks - less than thirteen Greenbacks.)
Bargain. Come on, YAM, get things going and back on the road!
Why do I feel relieved now that you're back home?
ReplyDeleteIt was quite an adventure that you had. And a lot of learning too. I must undertake a trip like that, I feel.
Hari OM
Delete...I don't know, Tom, why do you feel relieved?! 😂 It was the perfect first trip in this vehicle at just the right amount of time to 'learn' each other. There's still more to become familiar with in regards all the 'on board' functionality, but all the basics got ironed out. Travel is one of the greatest joys of life! Yxx
It does seem as if they are not particularly interested in encouraging EVs despite all the hot air about climate change, Teething problems hopefully that will be sorted out soon. Here's to your next! Cheers!
ReplyDelete‘They’ are pushing purchase down here but people are slow to uptake. Town driving’s not too bad but distance out in the bush is the killer.
ReplyDeleteCharging points don’t seem to be going in either unless heralded by much publicity (and government funding) Locally there’s been one trial ‘bank’ of several here in Bowen, with similar going into Proserpine (over an hours drive away) - no way will those towing a van invest in an EV
The buzz words ‘range anxiety’ is appearing more frequently - these are a recent press releases relating to Queensland
https://www.qld.gov.au/transport/projects/electricvehicles/super-highway
https://minister.dcceew.gov.au/bowen/media-releases/electric-vehicle-charging-network-connect-all-australia
Hari OM
DeleteActually, range anxiety is becoming less of a thing and it is more the 'finding a viable charger anxiety' that is starting to dominate! (This has been recognised by a number of the larger reporting points such as EVMan and Fully Charged) The realisation that the vast majority of driving in any given block is 100 miles or less, and most vehicles having more than that available, range is really not the issue. But if there is not a suitable place to obtain even a 10%/25mile top up charge at the end of that, then there can be a bit of tension.
Australia is well set to create one of the best EV networks... through solar charging. There has been significant surge forward since Albanese govt took over and the future there looks very promising as long as nothing comes along to stymie it! Yxx
Thanks for this interesting and detailed review. I am a bit surprised and disappointed that the charging costs were not cheaper. Less surprised that the whole situation regarding the need for a more reliable and streamlined charging network - this has been evident in several other articles I've read on the subject. Unfortunately, unless you have a home charger and do mostly local trips, the EV has some way to go before it matches a 'traditional' vehicle when it comes to convenience, and this will continue to be an obstacle to adoption for many lifestyles. Pioneers like yourself are to be thanked and congratulated for paving the way to a zero emissions future!
ReplyDeleteCheers, Gail.
Hari OM
DeleteIt is to be remembered that, currently, we are paying the full 20% VAT (sales tax) on electricity - that needs to be abolished just for starters. The prices had been a lot lower compared to fuel until last year and all the panic about energy costs that set in everywhere... and now the prices are set, one cannot see them dropping. Even in Scotland, some of the chargers I've seen had indicated price rise (but still well below that in England for the most part). Then there was the issue of paying parking fees on top of the charge costs... which is much less the case in Scotland (though I am aware that cities here are more likely to have these same restrictions and charges). That said, I do know of at least one parking spot nor far from here where folk have been caught out (Arrochar)... Hey ho... Yxx
that is a super quote... well done...
ReplyDeleteInteresting. My brother runs an NV200, in process of being fitted out as a camper, and an Energica motorbike...in June he was the first ever motorbike at the annual(( I think) Zaragoza rally in Spain. ( He is based in Somerset)
ReplyDeleteEcho Gail's comment. You are a pioneer and it is unfortunate that your experiences may discourage some less hardy or resilient seekers of a greener transport future, but good that you can report them in an objective summary like this. (F has her sister and BiL staying for a couple of nights - after all these years someone from downunder has finally visited our little corner of Hampshire.) Sending energy so you can tackle the next steps to targets. Xxx F
ReplyDeleteI suppose that any maiden voyage is a bit of a leap of faith, but it looks like you did well, YAM, and are set for more. You will be better equipped to handle these various issues and they will not come as a surprise. You can’t beat the cost!
ReplyDeleteHello,
ReplyDeleteWhat an adventure. You have learned a lot from this trip, it seems in the end the cost is still much cheaper than the cost of a hotel room for the night. If these electric vehicles are going to be the preferred way to go, the government has to have more reasonable charging stations available for all sizes of vehicles. I do like the machines where you can use your charge card to pay for your parking, it is more convenient than carrying a lot of cash or change. A lot of planning in advanced is probably best, to know exactly where to park overnight and charge your vehicle. Great report. Take care, have a great day and happy weekend.
at first when I read the cost of the charging I thought way to high, but then when you added it all together, 400 for a month away from home is cheaper than living at home for sure. I have no info on charging here, have never even seen a charging station, but I only fill the car at walmart, so they could be everywhere. I did get a chuckle out of on the open road doing 40/45, if you drive below 65/70 here you will get run off the road, honked at and cursed. you will see why if i ever finish my post about traffic. It sounds like a great deal to be, the cost and the joy you had on your trip. Traveling makes me crazy, so that will be one less traveler to get in the way of the ones like you who love to travel. I was born a homebody. When my grandmother died at my age of 15, it was a 12 hour drive, non stop to get to where her funeral was. I begged to stay at a friends house for the week, and since they did not want to travel 12 hours there and 12 back listening to my moans and groans they let me stay... one less traveler out there
ReplyDeleteReally well done, YAM! It is too bad they don't make recharging cheaper. It is helping the planet! A thoughtful debrief, as well. Glad you are happy with it all. XX
ReplyDeleteYAM I know HOW GOOD you are at research...The Grey is lucky to be loved by you.
ReplyDeleteOf course we don't have and EV so not very savvy on charging and charging stations.
Currently gasoline is about 3.59. We have two cars (BAR mobile) and CR-V. Both are good on gas. We alternate weeks of diving both. So we don't fill up much
Hugs cecilia
Sounds like you have a handle on the technical end of things!
ReplyDeleteHi Yam - I think it's amazing you were away for 6 weeks and happily enjoying the journey along the way ... it all sounds ideal - and you've learnt a great deal. Excellent summing up here - with all the ins and outs. It does sound like you've 'sussed out' most of the problems and possibilities etc - I guess in future you'll be able to judge where to legally park and plan ahead that way. Are you able to carry a top up battery with you ... I might have missed that part somewhere - all I can say is congratulations! Cheers Hilary
ReplyDelete